It's "trending" my friend. Yes, our current recruiting is very good and perhaps better than last year's class. But, will it wind up even the best in our conference? Baylor, not Texas, has the current upper hand.
Check out the recruiting by especially Baylor and also TCU for 2016. These teams have in recent years played us toe-to-toe or better even when their talent was significantly lesser than ours. Trends are a-changing and when their talent becomes eventually superior to ours, they will begin blowing us out, imho.
I don't believe we beat Baylor and TCU this year had Russell and Boykin played. We win in Stillwater no matter who QB'd the Pokes. So, my contention is that we would have been a 3 loss conference team had we not been extremely fortunate. Again, it's all one's perspective. You obviously disagree.
Wow! Can't believe where you put Bob on your list of the country's coaches. Again, perspective.
YOU said Bob has been a "great" coach over his tenure. I choose to use "fine" instead since his Natty year. Again, perspective. He's had some amazing victories and too many upset/heart-breaking losses in that tenure. I would say he was a "lucky" coach in 2015 following a crappy 2014.
Though nearly impossible, you've managed to compare Bob's volume of long-time work to Briles' relative short-term results at Baylor. The same with Patterson and TCU and Patterson has won every where he's been. Briles is trending better than Bob over the last 5 years and Patterson is also in the picture. Had either Briles - a repugnant thought for some here - and Patterson been our coach the last 17 years, it is my opinion that they would have delivered much more hardware than Bob. Obviously, you disagree.
Just look what Briles and Patterson were able to accomplish in this year's bowl games with their best talent missing.
Boomer Sooner
"
Yes, our current recruiting is very good and perhaps better than last year's class. But, will it wind up even the best in our conference?"
Bob never needed THE best recruiting class in the conference. Texas nearly always won that, but OU usually still came up on top.
And you admit that we're trending up, but just assume we will trend down again later.
"
Trends are a-changing and when their talent becomes eventually superior to ours, they will begin blowing us out, imho"
Most people believed their talent was already better than our this year, and we still won.
"
I don't believe we beat Baylor and TCU this year had Russell and Boykin played. We win in Stillwater no matter who QB'd the Pokes. So, my contention is that we would have been a 3 loss conference team had we not been extremely fortunate. Again, it's all one's perspective. You obviously disagree."
Clearly, I disagree. If TCU has Boykin all game and we have Mayfield all game, yes, we still win. Stidham was Russell's equal and we won.
Did you give Bob any leeway when OU lost key players like starting QBs in 2009 & 2014?
"
Wow! Can't believe where you put Bob on your list of the country's coaches. Again, perspective."
Yes. Perspective. Mine is based on rational thought and factual information. Yours seems to be based on what ifs.
"
YOU said Bob has been a "great" coach over his tenure. I choose to use "fine" instead since his Natty year. Again, perspective. He's had some amazing victories and too many upset/heart-breaking losses in that tenure. I would say he was a "lucky" coach in 2015 following a crappy 2014."
Yes, i did and I stand by it. I measure it based on what he has accomplished compared to other coaches, all-timers and contemporaries. In no logical way has Bob Stoops tenure at OU simply been "fine".
Aside from Meyer and Saban, who hasn't had a lot of upset heart-breakers? Didn't your beloved Patterson blow the Baylor game last year costing them the CFP? Wasn't Dabo Swinney known for several bouts of "Clemsoning" before this year? Didn't the all-time greats have bad stretches and lose big games? Yes, they all lost big games and have had bad stretches.
If 2015 had been his 1st conference title, maybe that would be luck. But when you've won 9,
it's because you're great at your job.
"
Though nearly impossible, you've managed to compare Bob's volume of long-time work to Briles' relative short-term results at Baylor. The same with Patterson and TCU and Patterson has won every where he's been. Briles is trending better than Bob over the last 5 years and Patterson is also in the picture. Had either Briles - a repugnant thought for some here - and Patterson been our coach the last 17 years, it is my opinion that they would have delivered much more hardware than Bob. Obviously, you disagree"
I also compared Bob's short-term work, both this year and when he firs took over OU.
OU was awful from 1994-1998 and was mediocre from 1989-1993. Bob Stoops got OU to the title game in year 2.
Why haven't Briles and Patterson gotten Baylor and TCU to that height in longer time?
Briles has been at Baylor for 8 years, Patterson at TCU for 15 years.
Neither is trending better than Bob as Bob beat them both and won the Big XII this year.
Patterson has won "everywhere he's been"? Exactly where is that? He's been TCU's head coach for 15 years, plus a bowl game the year before that. He's essentially been at TCU as long Bob has been at OU.
"
Just look what Briles and Patterson were able to accomplish in this year's bowl games with their best talent missing."
And Bob has done similarly in the past. Look at 2009 and 2013. We were missing a lot of talent by the time our bowl came around and pulled the upset in both.
And just look what Bob did against those two guys this year.
And just because a guy wins at a smaller school/lesser program doesn't mean they will be great at a major school. In fact, it usually doesn't happen. Examples:
Charlie Strong (Louisville - Texas)
Chris Petersen (Boise State - Washington)
Dennis Franchione (New Mexico - TCU - Alabama - Texas A&M)
Brady Hoke (Ball St. - SD State - Michigan)
Rich Rodriguez (West Virginia - Michigan)
Al Golden (Temple - Miami)
Steve Sarkisian (Washington - USC)
Ty Willingham (Stanford - Notre Dame)
Derek Dooley (La Tech - Tennessee)
Dirk Koetter (Boise State - Arizona State)
Dan Hawkins (Boise State - Colorado)
Tommy Bowden (Tulane - Clemson)
Gary Barnett (Northwestern - Colorado)
Jim Donnan (Marshall - Georgia)
Schnelly (Miami [small nothing program at the time] - Louisville - Oklahoma)
John Mackovic (Illinois - Texas)
Steve Kragthorpe (Tulsa - Louisville)
Some work out ok, most don't. This list could be a lot bigger if I felt like looking more up. Clearly, success at a lesser program doesn't guarantee success at a major program.