I'll be the first to admit that my football knowledge is pedestrian at best. It seems, though, that our current defensive scheme could use some improvement. While rushing only 3 with scattered help from the outside LBs, it appears we are rarely applying enough pressure to disrupt the quarterback. Add to that the lack of aggressive play and buffers given by the corners and LBs, we seem to allow too much positive execution by the opposing offense.
I know that there is a risk/reward component to all defensive schemes, but it appears to me the only way to counter the offensive production is to disrupt and play aggressively. It seems to work for other teams. Can it work for us?
While I understand what you're saying, too often we look at the most recent game to formulate opinions.
While it is still early in the season, through 5 games OU has 15 sacks, or 3 per game and averages 7 tackles for loss per game. We had 7 sacks against WV, which makes that stat a little misleading this early in the season, but also points out that we CAN disrupt the opposing QB.
The stats that concern me the most are our 39% defensive 3rd down conversion percentage and 190 rushing yds/game. Texas was obviously brutal, but against TU and WV we gave up 176 and 196 yards rushing respectively.
I really like how our secondary has progressed and it "seems" our DLine is getting a lot of attention via double teams. Tends to point back to the play of the LBs whose job it is to fill the gaps and stop the opposing team's running game from getting into our secondary. The relative irony is that it's likely our LBs are being "too" aggressive when they need to have the patience to read the play.
Bottom line, I think it's still too early to judge the "scheme" and we have had success disrupting opposing QBs. However, we REALLY need to improve our rushing D. I think it starts with our LBs.
Lastly, not defense...our offense has twice scored 24 points in regulation against 2 below average defenses. 60% of our OLine didn't have significant, if any, playing time until this year, we have a new play caller and a new QB. I saw weekly improvement through the first 4 games, but obviously regression last week.
Mayfield needs to find his rhythm earlier, the OLine needs to improve QUICKLY, and our new OC needs to figure out how to score more points against good defenses...also QUICKLY.
If we're going to win another Championship this year, we need to address and improve in the areas in
BOLD...starting this weekend.