I try not to put too much stock into rankings and player star evaluations. However, this is the most nondescript recruiting class in recent memory. Rivals has us 14th nationally which may be generous.
Of our 23 signees, 11 are three stars (zero five stars BTW) with no obvious difference makers on either side of the ball--particularly at the skill positions. The most possible exception is undersized WR Marvin Mims who plays a position at which we appear to have a surfeit of prospects.
On paper, we have recruited well in the lines with solid JUCO guys, which gives us the potential for added physicality in a conference that isn't overwhelmingly so. Until I see it assembled on the field, I have a hard time visualizing the structure of our future defenses. Alabama backed away from our top defensive recruit because they didn't believe he was aggressive enough for the SEC.
As an admittedly biased (and spoiled) Sooner fan, I believe we have to recruit consistently at a top five level to get over our well-documented playoff hump. I can't help but be very concerned that these types of classes won't even get us to the playoffs, let alone to a championship level. I also fear that our repeated playoff futility keeps many truly elite players from seriously considering us.
All of that said, nothing would make me happier than for these observations to be totally wrong and for this to be the most underrated Sooner recruiting class ever. Time will tell.
Of our 23 signees, 11 are three stars (zero five stars BTW) with no obvious difference makers on either side of the ball--particularly at the skill positions. The most possible exception is undersized WR Marvin Mims who plays a position at which we appear to have a surfeit of prospects.
On paper, we have recruited well in the lines with solid JUCO guys, which gives us the potential for added physicality in a conference that isn't overwhelmingly so. Until I see it assembled on the field, I have a hard time visualizing the structure of our future defenses. Alabama backed away from our top defensive recruit because they didn't believe he was aggressive enough for the SEC.
As an admittedly biased (and spoiled) Sooner fan, I believe we have to recruit consistently at a top five level to get over our well-documented playoff hump. I can't help but be very concerned that these types of classes won't even get us to the playoffs, let alone to a championship level. I also fear that our repeated playoff futility keeps many truly elite players from seriously considering us.
All of that said, nothing would make me happier than for these observations to be totally wrong and for this to be the most underrated Sooner recruiting class ever. Time will tell.
Last edited: