ADVERTISEMENT

OT: Movie Review - The Homesman

Schoonerman

Sooner starter
May 29, 2001
20,915
3,135
113
68
Marietta, GA
Hadn't seen a western in a while, so I was really looking forward to this one.

The Homesman stars Hillary Swank as a strong-willed, confident and resourceful woman living by herself in a small pioneer community in western Nebraska during the 1870s (?). The harshness of living on the front range is hard on everyone, but three women in the area have become mentally unstable living in the unfriendly and unforgiving life on the open prairie. The women need to be taken back east to a church in Iowa where the minister and his wife will care for these women who have lost their minds and are about to lose their lives. Swank is the only one strong enough and has the resources to take these women on their journey, so she signs up.

While procuring her wagons, horses and supplies for the trip, she comes across a low-life squatter played by Tommy Lee Jones. Jones has been routed out of the cabin he had been squatting in and was left to die in the wilderness when Swanks saves his life. He agrees to repay her for saving him by going on the trip, as long as she pays him $300 when the women are delivered to the minister.

The trip is perilous as the group must face difficulties with the weather, Indians, other travelers and even themselves. The three mentally ill women present challenges themselves and are like an albatross hanging round the neck of Swank and Jones, making the journey even more difficult. There is a surprising twist at the end of the story that is quite dramatic and alters the direction of the movie, almost to the point where the ending is anti-climactic. I really was into this movie, but the last 20 minutes left me flat and wondering why the writer took it in the direction that he did. I realize it was a powerful statement, but the movie just drifted toward the ending, which I found a little disappointing.

I liked the first 90 minutes of the movie, but the last 15 minutes was just so-so. With that said, this one barely makes a 7 out of 10 Sooner Schooners.
 
good review and I agree. the twist didn't really fit the movie or that character.
 
Originally posted by stuck in del rio:
Thanks - I'd be interested to read your review of St. Vincent.
Wow. Funny you mentioned St. Vincent. Watched it again today with the wifey. Cold and rainy today, so a good day to watch a movie.

I already did this one, but loved it and everyone in the movie. Great cast, loved the message and think Murray's deadpan delivery of the rude and crusty Vincent was brilliant. Naomi Watts killed it as his Russian girlfriend/dancer/prostitute. I think I commented that this was a great film for Melissa McCarthy as she got to have some funny lines, but also served up Murray as well and this was a nice role for her as opposed to some of the over-the-top characters she's played in other roles.

I recall giving St. Vincent 9.5 out of 10 Sooner Schooners.
 
Originally posted by Schoonerman:

Originally posted by stuck in del rio:
Thanks - I'd be interested to read your review of St. Vincent.
Wow. Funny you mentioned St. Vincent. Watched it again today with the wifey. Cold and rainy today, so a good day to watch a movie.

I already did this one, but loved it and everyone in the movie. Great cast, loved the message and think Murray's deadpan delivery of the rude and crusty Vincent was brilliant. Naomi Watts killed it as his Russian girlfriend/dancer/prostitute. I think I commented that this was a great film for Melissa McCarthy as she got to have some funny lines, but also served up Murray as well and this was a nice role for her as opposed to some of the over-the-top characters she's played in other roles.

I recall giving St. Vincent 9.5 out of 10 Sooner Schooners.
I thought Murray was great, some of his best work since I don't know when. The kid was very good, and you're right about McCarthy -- nice to see her do something besides be the female John Belushi - she's typecast about as much as Leonard Nimoy. I thought this was one of the better movies I've seen for 2014 movies.
 
Originally posted by Schoonerman:

Hadn't seen a western in a while, so I was really looking forward to this one.

The Homesman stars Hillary Swank as a strong-willed, confident and resourceful woman living by herself in a small pioneer community in western Nebraska during the 1870s (?). The harshness of living on the front range is hard on everyone, but three women in the area have become mentally unstable living in the unfriendly and unforgiving life on the open prairie. The women need to be taken back east to a church in Iowa where the minister and his wife will care for these women who have lost their minds and are about to lose their lives. Swank is the only one strong enough and has the resources to take these women on their journey, so she signs up.

While procuring her wagons, horses and supplies for the trip, she comes across a low-life squatter played by Tommy Lee Jones. Jones has been routed out of the cabin he had been squatting in and was left to die in the wilderness when Swanks saves his life. He agrees to repay her for saving him by going on the trip, as long as she pays him $300 when the women are delivered to the minister.

The trip is perilous as the group must face difficulties with the weather, Indians, other travelers and even themselves. The three mentally ill women present challenges themselves and are like an albatross hanging round the neck of Swank and Jones, making the journey even more difficult. There is a surprising twist at the end of the story that is quite dramatic and alters the direction of the movie, almost to the point where the ending is anti-climactic. I really was into this movie, but the last 20 minutes left me flat and wondering why the writer took it in the direction that he did. I realize it was a powerful statement, but the movie just drifted toward the ending, which I found a little disappointing.

I liked the first 90 minutes of the movie, but the last 15 minutes was just so-so. With that said, this one barely makes a 7 out of 10 Sooner Schooners.
I pulled this movie up and watched it because you gad reviewed it. You were very accurate - I didn't see the plot twist coming either. As someone else wrote, it was a weird twist, almost like they put it in just to have a twist. Loved the hotel scene but I am a huge James Spader fan. The ending dragged, seemed lost.

I watched Selena or Serena about a week ago, I think it comes out this week - I was looking forward to it because I enjoyed Brad Cooper and Jennifer Lawrence in Silver Linings Playbook a lot, but this one was weird - good to begin, but then got twisted...might have been me.

I'm watching Whiplash now - I'm hoping to see all the Oscar nominated movies in the next week or so.
 
Originally posted by stuck in del rio:

Originally posted by Schoonerman:

Hadn't seen a western in a while, so I was really looking forward to this one.

The Homesman stars Hillary Swank as a strong-willed, confident and resourceful woman living by herself in a small pioneer community in western Nebraska during the 1870s (?). The harshness of living on the front range is hard on everyone, but three women in the area have become mentally unstable living in the unfriendly and unforgiving life on the open prairie. The women need to be taken back east to a church in Iowa where the minister and his wife will care for these women who have lost their minds and are about to lose their lives. Swank is the only one strong enough and has the resources to take these women on their journey, so she signs up.

While procuring her wagons, horses and supplies for the trip, she comes across a low-life squatter played by Tommy Lee Jones. Jones has been routed out of the cabin he had been squatting in and was left to die in the wilderness when Swanks saves his life. He agrees to repay her for saving him by going on the trip, as long as she pays him $300 when the women are delivered to the minister.

The trip is perilous as the group must face difficulties with the weather, Indians, other travelers and even themselves. The three mentally ill women present challenges themselves and are like an albatross hanging round the neck of Swank and Jones, making the journey even more difficult. There is a surprising twist at the end of the story that is quite dramatic and alters the direction of the movie, almost to the point where the ending is anti-climactic. I really was into this movie, but the last 20 minutes left me flat and wondering why the writer took it in the direction that he did. I realize it was a powerful statement, but the movie just drifted toward the ending, which I found a little disappointing.

I liked the first 90 minutes of the movie, but the last 15 minutes was just so-so. With that said, this one barely makes a 7 out of 10 Sooner Schooners.
I pulled this movie up and watched it because you gad reviewed it. You were very accurate - I didn't see the plot twist coming either. As someone else wrote, it was a weird twist, almost like they put it in just to have a twist. Loved the hotel scene but I am a huge James Spader fan. The ending dragged, seemed lost.

I watched Selena or Serena about a week ago, I think it comes out this week - I was looking forward to it because I enjoyed Brad Cooper and Jennifer Lawrence in Silver Linings Playbook a lot, but this one was weird - good to begin, but then got twisted...might have been me.

I'm watching Whiplash now - I'm hoping to see all the Oscar nominated movies in the next week or so.
Whiplash and Imitation of Life are the next two on my list. I was so-so about seeing Whiplash, but after seeing the clips and doing a little reading on it, it has my interest. Besides, I really like JK Simmons (Juno's dad
3dgrin.r191677.gif
).
 
Good, but depressing movie. I thought the murder of a baby was very disturbing, but I understand how that scene was intended.
 
Originally posted by Schoonerman:

Whiplash and Imitation of Life are the next two on my list. I was so-so about seeing Whiplash, but after seeing the clips and doing a little reading on it, it has my interest. Besides, I really like JK Simmons (Juno's dad
3dgrin.r191677.gif
).
I didn't think I would be all that interested in Whiplash, but it surprised me - Simmons is fantastic, that's an Oscar well-earned...course he plays an insufferable prick that is sometimes hard to watch, sort of what Schmitty would be if he taught music (no offense intended, and I'm not equating football to music)...Imitation of Life is very good, I thoroughly enjoyed watching it, and might watch it again tonight. Very good movie. I also thought Theory of Everything was good, touching in places.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT