I know Tua is great, but the difference for me is you have to ask, "Where would each team be without their quarterback?" Without Tua Alabama is still undefeated and still the clear cut favorite to win the national title. Without Kyler we would be in big trouble this season. Army, Texas (still haven't played OSU, Iowa State or WV or Big 12 title game or bowl game). To me that is the deciding factor - Bama without Tua wouldn't miss a beat. OU without Kyler? Might be in trouble...
